SCHEDULE 14A
INFORMATION
Proxy Statement
Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
(Amendment No. ____)
Filed by the Registrant [ ]
Filed by
a Party other than the Registrant [X]
Check the appropriate box:
[ ] |
Preliminary
Proxy Statement |
[ ] |
Confidential,
for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2)) |
[ ] |
Definitive
Proxy Statement |
[ ] |
Definitive
Additional Materials |
[X] |
Soliciting
Material under Rule 14a-12 |
BANCORP RHODE
ISLAND, INC.
(Name of Registrant as Specified in its Charter)
Financial Edge Fund,
L.P.
PL Capital, LLC
Goodbody/PL Capital, LLC
Financial Edge-Strategic Fund, L.P.
PL
Capital/Focused Fund, L.P.
Goodbody/PL Capital, L.P.
PL Capital Advisors, LLC
Richard J.
Lashley
John W. Palmer
(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement if other than the
Registrant)
Payment of Filing Fee (Check the
appropriate box):
[ ] |
Fee
computed on table below per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11. |
|
1. |
Title
of each class of securities to which transaction applies: |
|
2. |
Aggregate
number of securities to which transaction applies: |
|
3. |
Per
unit price or other underlying value of transaction computed pursuant to
Exchange Act Rule 0-11 (Set forth the amount on which the filing fee is
calculated and state how it was determined): |
|
4. |
Proposed
maximum aggregate value of transaction: |
[ ] |
Fee
paid previously with preliminary materials. |
[ ] |
Check
box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule
0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid
previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or
the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing. |
|
1. |
Amount
Previously Paid: |
|
2. |
Form,
Schedule or Registration Statement No.: |
Filed by PL Capital
Group
On
February 2, 2009, PL Capital Group issued a press release related to Bancorp Rhode Island,
Inc. and PL Capital Groups potential submission of corporate governance proposals
for approval by stockholders at Bancorp Rhode Islands 2009 Annual Meeting of
Stockholders. A copy of the press release follows as part of this filing under Rule 14a-12
of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended.
Important Information
PL
Capital Group currently intends to file a definitive proxy statement with the Securities
and Exchange Commission (the SEC) in connection with PL Capital Groups
potential submission of corporate governance proposals for approval by stockholders at
Bancorp Rhode Islands 2009 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. The definitive proxy
statement and proxy card will be sent to stockholders of Bancorp Rhode Island
seeking their support of the corporate governance proposals at Bancorp Rhode Islands
2009 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. Stockholders are urged to read the definitive
proxy statement and proxy card when they become available, because they will contain
important information about the corporate governance proposals submitted by PL Capital
Group and related matters. Stockholders may obtain a free copy of the definitive proxy
statement (when available) and other documents filed by PL Capital Group with the SEC at
the SECs web site at www.sec.gov. The definitive proxy statement (when available)
and other related SEC documents filed by PL Capital Group with the SEC may also be
obtained free of charge from PL Capital Group.
PL
Capital Group consists of the following persons who will be participants in the
solicitation from Bancorp Rhode Island, Inc.s stockholders of proxies in favor of PL
Capital Groups corporate governance proposals: PL Capital, LLC; Goodbody/PL Capital,
LLC; Financial Edge Fund, L.P.; Financial Edge-Strategic Fund, L.P.; PL Capital/Focused
Fund, L.P.; Goodbody/PL Capital, L.P.; PL Capital Advisors, LLC; Richard J. Lashley; and
John W. Palmer. Such participants may have interests in the solicitation, including as a
result of holding shares of Bancorp Rhode Island common stock. Information regarding
the participants and their interests will be contained in the definitive proxy statement
to be filed by PL Capital Group with the SEC in connection with Bancorp Rhode
Islands 2009 Annual Meeting of Stockholders.
PL CAPITAL INFORMS BANCORP RHODE
ISLANDS BOARD OF (1) ITS INTENT TO SOLICIT PROXIES AT THE 2009 ANNUAL MEETING
SEEKING IMPROVEMENTS IN CORPORATE GOVERNANCE, AND (2) BANCORP RHODE ISLAND
MANAGEMENTS MISHANDLED CONFERENCE CALL ON JANUARY 29, 2009
Naperville, IL February 2, 2009 PR
Newswire/ On January 30, 2009, the PL Capital Group sent a letter to the board of
directors of Bancorp Rhode Island, Inc. (NASDAQ: BARI), informing them of (1) PL
Capitals intent to solicit proxies from fellow shareholders of Bancorp Rhode Island
at the 2009 Annual Meeting of Shareholders and (2) Bancorp Rhode Island managements
mishandling of an important conference call with analysts, investors and shareholders on
January 29, 2009.
The PL Capital Group plans to issue
its own proxy statement containing, among other things, the following shareholder
proposals:
|
|
Majority
Voting Standard-in an uncontested election, any director that fails to garner a
majority of affirmative votes cast FOR their election will have to tender their
resignation |
|
|
Declassified
Board-each and every director stands for election annually |
|
|
Reduction
in the size of the Board-Bancorp Rhode Island currently has fifteen directors; in PL
Capitals view a board that large is unsupportable in todays economy (too
expensive); in PL Capitals view a much smaller board would also be more responsive
and effective |
If these proposals are approved
by shareholders and adopted by Bancorp Rhode Island, it would help ensure the boards
accountability to shareholders, each and every year, even in uncontested elections,
noted PL Capital principal Rich Lashley. Bancorp Rhode Islands board missed
several critical opportunities to maximize shareholder value in 2006 and 2007, and
management has failed to improve the performance of Bancorp Rhode Island as they promised.
Shareholders deserve the right to cast a vote for directors each year that actually
counts, Mr. Lashley added.
The majority voting and
declassified board standards that we are proposing are widely considered to be the gold
standard in corporate governance. We have asked the board of directors of Bancorp Rhode
Island to adopt these standards unilaterally, before the 2009 Annual Meeting and without
the need for a proxy contest, noted PL Capital principal John Palmer. We hope
the board members place the interests of shareholders ahead of their own, Mr. Palmer
added.
PL Capitals letter to the board
of directors contained the following excerpts with regard to Bancorp Rhode Islands
performance and the decisions made by the board in the past few years, which led to PL
Capitals decision to seek these proposals:
|
THE
BOARD AND MANAGEMENT OF BANCORP RHODE ISLAND FAILED TO MAXIMIZE SHAREHOLDER VALUE AND
IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE OF THE COMPANY AS PROMISED |
|
When
Rich Lashley informed CEO Merrill Sherman in December 2007 that PL Capital was planning
to run a proxy contest for three board seats at the May 2008 Annual Meeting, she seemed
genuinely surprised that we felt the need to do that. She tried to convince him that it
was unnecessary, saying that the board and management were focused on shareholder value
and a proxy fight would interfere with the Companys ability and intent to maximize
shareholder value. In a subsequent letter to shareholders, the Company noted that your
Board, consistent with its fiduciary obligations, has always taken and will continue to
take responsible and appropriate steps in evaluating all opportunities to enhance
shareholder value, including potential mergers and acquisitions. That same letter
also noted that an investment bank had been advising the board on strategic matters
including the banking industry marketplace and all potential value-creating
opportunities. Ms. Sherman also made representations to shareholders that a vote
for PL Capital was a vote for a fire sale and that the current board and
management would maximize shareholder value on its own. |
|
As
you well know, we ran a proxy contest in 2007 and 2008 because we did not believe Ms.
Shermans and the boards representations about the intent to maximize the
value of the franchise. We also felt compelled to run the proxy contests because it
seemed clear to us that the Companys performance was not going to improve
materially. You must recall the numerous times we noted that the efficiency ratio was
stuck in the 65% to 75% range when it should be 55% to 60%, the Return on Equity (ROE)
was unlikely to significantly exceed 8% anytime soon, and because of this performance
something had to change. We stated our belief that either new leadership should be
brought in (starting at the top, with CEO Ms. Sherman) or the Company should be sold
while it could obtain a high premium, reflective of the Companys scarcity value and
the relative health of the economy and bank merger market at that time. |
|
In
hindsight, we were correct, and still are. Unfortunately, the board and management have
stayed the course and produced the following results, which we believe demonstrate the
failure of the board and management to maximize shareholder value and improve the
performance of the Company as promised: |
|
|
BancorpRIs
stock declined 56% from a high of approximately $45 in late 2006 and early 2007
(which happens to coincide with PL Capitals announced intent to run for board seats
and push the Company to maximize shareholder value) to the current price of $19.75 (on
January 29, 2009, shortly after the most recent Q4 2008 conference call, which did not go
well in our viewsee below); |
|
|
BancorpRIs
ROE in 2006 (7.22%), 2007 (7.87%) and 2008 (8.01%) remained capped at the 8% level,
as we predicted, well below the 10%+ ROEs produced in 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004 and
2005; |
|
|
Managements
most recent guidance is for BancorpRI to earn approximately $1.60 to $1.70 per share in
2009, down from $1.96 per share in 2008; this implies a 2009 ROE of approximately 6%;
and |
|
|
BancorpRIs
efficiency ratio in 2006 (75.6%), 2007 (73.0%) and 2008 (67.7%) remained stuck in the
65% to 75% range we predicted, well above the 60% to 65% efficiency ratios
produced in 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001 and 2002, and well above the 55% to 60% level achieved
by many peers. |
|
In
our view, there is no doubt that by not selling BancorpRI in 2006 or 2007, the board
missed a significant opportunity to maximize shareholder value. In 2007, a research
analyst at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods (KBW) was quoted as saying that the BancorpRI
franchise was worth approximately $44 per share in a sale. Other analysts previously
opined that BancorpRI could be worth more than $50 per share in a sale. By most accounts,
those levels were achievable if the board and management team had acted in 2006 or 2007. |
|
CEO
Merrill Sherman disagreed with our assessment, saying on numerous occasions that the
shareholder value of BancorpRI would be maximized by growing the franchise instead of
selling it. Despite her efforts and (we believe limited) success in growing the franchise
and earnings, she and the board were wrong. The franchise value of BancorpRI is lower
today than it was at any time in 2006 and 2007. It may take years, if ever, to recover
the franchise value premium that could have been achieved in a 2006 or 2007 sale. |
|
While
we understand why a CEO who makes in excess of $1.0 million per year in total
compensation running a public company would not want to admit that shareholders could be
better served by selling the company (or stepping down so a more highly qualified bank
executive could become CEO), we find it difficult to understand why the board failed to
make this judgment. We are not holding the board accountable for not foreseeing the
credit crunch or the severe recession, which has made the problems even worse. We are
merely saying that we believe it was fairly easy to see that conditions in 2006 and 2007
(in the economy and the bank merger market) were very unlikely to improve and that
waiting was a strategic mistake, as the Companys performance was unlikely to
materially improve. |
************************
Bancorp Rhode
Islands Management Mishandled an Important Conference Call with Analysts and
Investors
On January 29, 2009 the management of
Bancorp Rhode Island, CEO Merrill Sherman and CFO Linda Simmons, held a conference call to
discuss the results for Q4 2008 and the year ended 2008. In that call, they also provided
guidance for 2009. The call was mishandled in PL Capitals view, for the reasons
noted below, which were included in PL Capitals letter of January 30, 2009 to the
board of Bancorp Rhode Island, excerpts of which follow:
|
THE
MOST RECENT Q4 2008 CONFERENCE CALL WAS MISHANDLEDHURTING THE CEOS AND COMPANYS
CREDIBILITY |
|
At
a time when shareholder and analyst angst is high and patience low, the Company decided
to abruptly cut off the Q4 2008 and 2009 Guidance conference call after only 28 minutes,
most of which was filled with managements presentation. Only three callers were
allowed to ask questions. We had several questions to ask and were waiting in the queue
when the call suddenly ended. We are sure there were others that were cut-off as well. No
warning was given that the call would be truncated so quickly. If analysts and
shareholders were willing to remain on the line to ask questions, then management should
have stayed on until all questions were asked and answered. This was not the first time
this happened. You should recall a similar episode when management admitted that they
purposely blocked us from asking questions on a quarterly conference call. |
|
We
believe the truncated Q4 2008 and 2009 Guidance conference call is just another example
of how poorly the Company and management treat shareholders. We recall how we and other
shareholders were given limited time to speak and ask questions at the last two
shareholders meetings. We also recall the unprofessional and embarrassing behavior
of board member Anthony Tony the Barber Andrade (his description, not ours)
at the May 2008 Annual Meeting. The board should be embarrassed by this behavior. |
|
One
lesson we have learned repeatedly over the years is that the companies, CEOs and CFOs who
are open, transparent and available for questions (and even criticism) are the ones that
get the benefit of the doubt, especially in tough times. Based on the actions we have
seen, this management team has not demonstrated openness and transparency, nor
demonstrated a willingness to listen to shareholders. |
|
For
example, the Q4 2008 press release was not issued in its entirety until one-half hour
before the call began. Even if the press release had been issued normally, it would not
have been timely. The quarterly press release is normally released at 8 a.m., two hours
before the call begins, a time frame we have objected to several times with management,
to no avail. Very few public companies have that short of a window between the press
release and the conference call, and we believe that it is inappropriate and serves no
purpose. There is no apparent reason why the press release is not issued the afternoon
before the next mornings conference call. |
|
Further,
we believe the tone at the top is not conducive to good shareholder relations.
Specifically, CEO Merrill Sherman has demonstrated to us a reluctance to be open and deal
with shareholders in a productive and respectful manner. Whether she realizes it or not,
we have observed that she becomes notably impatient and curt when anyone questions her or
requests more in-depth responses. In our conversations with her, she also typically
refuses to answer any question in-depth, by invoking Regulation FD. We talk
to CEOs and CFOs constantly, and none of them hide behind Regulation FD as
often as she does. |
Contact: |
Richard Lashley |
John W. Palmer |
|
973-360-1666 |
630-848-1340 |
|
Bankfund@aol.com |
Palmersail@aol.com |
Important Information
PL Capital Group currently intends to
file a definitive proxy statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the
SEC) in connection with PL Capital Groups potential submission of
corporate governance proposals for approval by stockholders at Bancorp Rhode Islands
2009 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. The definitive proxy statement and proxy card
will be sent to stockholders of Bancorp Rhode Island seeking their support of the
corporate governance proposals at Bancorp Rhode Islands 2009 Annual Meeting of
Stockholders. Stockholders are urged to read the definitive proxy statement and
proxy card when they become available, because they will contain important information
about the corporate governance proposals submitted by PL Capital Group and related
matters. Stockholders may obtain a free copy of the definitive proxy statement (when
available) and other documents filed by PL Capital Group with the SEC at the SECs
web site at www.sec.gov. The definitive proxy statement (when available) and other related
SEC documents filed by PL Capital Group with the SEC may also be obtained free of charge
from PL Capital Group.
Participants in
Solicitation
PL Capital Group consists of the following
persons who will be participants in the solicitation from Bancorp Rhode Island,
Inc.s stockholders of proxies in favor of PL Capital Groups corporate
governance proposals: PL Capital, LLC; Goodbody/PL Capital, LLC; Financial Edge Fund,
L.P.; Financial Edge-Strategic Fund, L.P.; PL Capital/Focused Fund, L.P.; Goodbody/PL
Capital, L.P.; PL Capital Advisors, LLC; Richard J. Lashley; and John W. Palmer. Such
participants may have interests in the solicitation, including as a result of holding
shares of Bancorp Rhode Island common stock. Information regarding the participants and
their interests will be contained in the definitive proxy statement to be filed by PL
Capital Group with the SEC in connection with Bancorp Rhode Islands 2009 Annual
Meeting of Stockholders.